(CBS/AP) NEW YORK - Overtime heroics, acrobatic goaltending and a captain's guarantee marked the last time the New York Rangers and the New Jersey Devils battled for the right to play for the Stanley Cup.
If this year's sequel lives up to the original, it will be one for the ages.
Eighteen years ago, it was Stephane Matteau forever etching his name into hockey history with a double-overtime wraparound goal that launched the Rangers into the finals on their way to the franchise's first Stanley Cup in 54 years.
The intensity and animosity has only grown over the past two decades. The Devils recovered well from the disappointment of losing such an important series to their so-called "big brothers," and went on to win the Stanley Cup three times between 1995 and 2003, with another finals loss mixed in.
The Rangers haven't come close to matching that run of success. This is New York's first appearance in the conference finals since 1997 a 4-1 series loss to Philadelphia.
Most of the names have changed from that landmark series back in 1994. Devils goalie Martin Brodeur, who conceded the decisive goal to Matteau, is the only player from either team to still be in the NHL, and he is still the cornerstone of the New Jersey club that will face the Rangers in this year's East finals that open Monday night at Madison Square Garden.
No, there won't be any "Matt-eau, Matt-eau, Matt-eau" calls in this one. But that doesn't mean a similar situation won't occur in another dramatic Game 7, and a name such as "Kovy, Kovy" in a Devils win or "Cally, Cally" for the Rangers will instantly become as big a part of the rivalry lore.
Brodeur is excited to be at the center of it again.
"I guess it's kind of amazing when you look at the amount of years in between the two series," he said Sunday. "A lot of things have changed since `94, as far as the media is concerned.
"I expect it to be just the same for the guys. They have to just enjoy the moment. This is a great time in everybody's lives, and we need to really take it all in. You never know when you're going to get back in the situation that you're going to play for a chance to go to the Stanley Cup finals. Playing against our biggest rival, kind of puts a cherry on top."
The names have certainly changed, but the intensity hasn't between these Atlantic Division rivals. During the regular season, the teams split six games. The most recent meeting on March 19 was the most memorable as it began with the clubs' enforcers on the ice and led to three fights right off the opening faceoff.
A repeat of that is unlikely, but feistiness and nastiness is almost a guarantee between these defensive-minded teams that value each and every goal, and know that any one could be the difference between a win and a loss.
"I think it's going to be physical," Rangers captain Ryan Callahan said. "Both teams like to play that style. They've been chippy games every time we played them in the regular season. I don't see that changing.
"At the same time you have to make sure you're disciplined, don't get too emotional out there. I'm sure you're not going to see guys fighting on an opening faceoff, but it's going to be intense."
New York coach John Tortorella made it clear Saturday night after the Rangers secured their place in the conference finals that he wasn't going to be sucked into any hoopla surrounding this juicy matchup.
"You guys can make your stories about the Devils-Rangers, and I know you're going to do it in the next couple weeks. Don't include me in it," Tortorella said. "We are going to worry about the New York Rangers."
Which is plenty.
Devils coach Peter DeBoer, who drew the ire of Tortorella because of the lineup he started back in March, left practice early on Sunday because he wasn't feeling well. But he was healthy enough to provide his thoughts on a conference call with reporters.
He said he watched the Rangers-Capitals finale, and did so without a rooting interest. Only seven points separated the top-seeded Rangers from the sixth-seeded Devils in the regular season.
"For me, it was a pick-your-poison type situation," the first-year Devils coach said. "I really think that there's a reason that there's only four teams left, and they're all very good.
"I am excited it's the Rangers. Anybody that coaches or plays wants to play your main rival in this type of situation. I don't think it gets any better than that. We're very excited that we'll get an opportunity at the best team in the Eastern Conference. They have the most points, and we're going to throw our best at them and see if it's good enough."
Close, tight games seem to be in store, just as it was in 1994 when Matteau's goal gave the Rangers a 2-1 victory. Three of those seven games went to double overtime back then, and two of those were won off Matteau's stick. The other, Game 1, was won with a Stephane Richer goal for New Jersey at Madison Square Garden.
All told, that 1994 series featured 27 periods of hockey, two suspensions, and a promise from New York captain Mark Messier that turned into "The Guarantee" of a Game 6 win. He delivered on it, the Rangers rallied from a 3-2 series deficit and a 2-0 hole in Game 6 itself, with Messier netting a hat trick in the process. Two weeks later, he was hoisting the Stanley Cup in front of New York fans starved of silverware since 1940.
"It was a different game back then," said former Rangers forward Adam Graves, whose No. 9 hangs from the Garden rafters, largely for what he did in that season. "I just remember how much of a war it was and how you had to fight for every inch, and the battles in front of the net. I can remember physically how taxing it was going against guys like (Ken) Daneyko and (Scott) Stevens and just the battles in the corner.
"That is vivid in my mind."
The Rangers returned to practice on Sunday albeit an optional one just hours after they knocked out the Washington Capitals with a 2-1 win in Game 7. Sound familiar?
New York is quite used to going the distance. The Rangers did it in each of the final two rounds in 1994 and they have done it again in the first two rounds this year taking out Ottawa to set up the meeting with Washington. While they embrace the history of their 1994 Game 7 success, they also know that no team pushed to the limit in each of the first two rounds has gone on to capture the Cup.
That sparks the age-old rest vs. rust debate. Yes, the Rangers have played the maximum 14 games in the first two rounds, but the Devils will have had five days off before facing the Rangers since they eliminated Philadelphia in five games.
"If you're playing in June in the seventh game, you went through the whole thing, you might be able to read into something like that," Rangers forward Brad Richards said. "We're just halfway. We're a young team. We should be excited and energetic going into this. I don't think anybody is going to be tired."
Mike Rupp has been on both sides of this battle. He began his career with the Devils in the 2002-03 season, and scored the Stanley Cup-winning goal in Game 7 against the Anaheim Ducks. After stops in Phoenix and Columbus, Rupp returned to New Jersey for three more seasons.
He just finished his first with the Rangers, and still remembers clearly what it was like to face them on the ice. New York has won four of its five playoff matchups against New Jersey, including the most recent meeting in 2008 when the Rangers won in five games.
"It's just a rivalry of territory in this area," Rupp said. "In the playoffs there would be more blue jerseys than red (in New Jersey). It was kind of one of those things that made you hate them more. I got to see it from the other side this year.
"It's one of those great rivalries in the game and it should be a good series."